Bishop Tobin: The Intentional Ambiguity of #AmorisLaetitia

Bishop Tobin
Bishop Tobin

The Intentional Ambiguity of “Amoris Laetitia”

Upon reflection, it’s become pretty clear that Pope Francis’ document on marriage and the family, “Amoris Laetitia,” is marked by ambiguity, and that’s intentional on the Holy Father’s part I think.
That explains why, in just the last couple of days, we’ve had very different interpretations of the document from two prominent leaders of the Church – Archbishop Charles Chaput of Philadelphia and Cardinal Christoph Schonborn of Vienna. And from many other commentators as well.
The good news is, that because of this ambiguity, people can do just about whatever they want. The bad news is, that because of this ambiguity, people can do just about whatever they want.
Go figure! – Bishop Thomas J. Tobin, July 7 at 4:54pm

Capture Tobin on AL

Cf. facebook link.

Recall in 2014:

— Pope Francis is fond of “creating a mess.” Mission accomplished.
— Relax. God’s still in charge.

Facebook: Bishop Thomas J. Tobin, October 20, 2014 | Random Thoughts About the Synod on the Family:

Cardinal Sarah’s AD ORIENTAM call – In his own words.

Robert Cardinal Sarah
Robert Cardinal Sarah


I want to make an appeal to all priests. You may have read my article in L’Osservatore Romano one year ago (12 June 2015) or my interview with the journal Famille Chrétienne in May of this year. On both occasions I said that I believe that it is very important that we return as soon as possible to a common orientation, of priests and the faithful turned together in the same direction—Eastwards or at least towards the apse—to the Lord who comes, in those parts of the liturgical rites when we are addressing God. This practice is permitted by current liturgical legislation. It is perfectly legitimate in the modern rite. Indeed, I think it is a very important step in ensuring that in our celebrations the Lord is truly at the centre.

And so, dear Fathers, I humbly and fraternally ask you to implement this practice wherever possible, with prudence and with the necessary catechesis, certainly, but also with a pastor’s confidence that this is something good for the Church, something good for our people. Your own pastoral judgement will determine how and when this is possible, but perhaps beginning this on the first Sunday of Advent this year, when we attend ‘the Lord who will come’ and ‘who will not delay’ (see: Introit, Mass of Wednesday of the first week of Advent) may be a very good time to do this. Dear Fathers, we should listen again to the lament of God proclaimed by the prophet Jeremiah: “they have turned their backs to me and not their faces” (2:27). Let us turn again towards the Lord! Since the day of his Baptism, the Christian knows only one direction: the Orient. “You entered to confront your enemy, for you intended to renounce him to his face. You turned toward the East (ad Orientem), for one who renounces the devil turns towards Christ and fixes his gaze directly on Him” (From the beginning of the Treatise on the Mysteries by Saint Ambrose, Bishop of Milan).

Cf. Cardinal Sarah emphasizes importance of silence, ad orientem celebration, October 04, 2016 | Catholic Culture

Renewing his invitation to priests to celebrate Mass ad orientem, accompanied by catechesis, he said:

This way of doing things promotes silence. Indeed, there is less of a temptation for the celebrant to monopolize the conversation. Facing the Lord, he is less tempted to become a professor who gives a lecture during the whole Mass, reducing the altar to a podium centered no longer on the cross but on the microphone! The priest must remember that he is only an instrument in Christ’s hands, that he must be quiet in order to make room for the Word, and that our human words are ridiculous compared to the one Eternal Word.

I am convinced that priests do not use the same tone of voice when they celebrate facing East. We are so much less tempted to take ourselves for actors, as Pope Francis says!

Cf. The Reform of the Reform “Will Happen.” The Pope Wants It, Too, ROME, by Sandro Magister, October 6, 2016 | WWW.CHIESA


I refuse to waste time in opposing one liturgy to another, or the rite of Saint Pius V to that of Blessed Paul VI. What is needed is to enter into the great silence of the liturgy; one must allow oneself to be enriched by all the Latin or Eastern liturgical forms that favor silence. Without this contemplative silence, the liturgy will remain an occasion of hateful divisions and ideological confrontations instead of being the place of our unity and our communion in the Lord. It is high time to enter into this liturgical silence, facing the Lord, that the Council wanted to restore.

What I am about to say now does not enter into contradiction with my submission and obedience to the supreme authority of the Church. I desire profoundly and humbly to serve God, the Church, and the Holy Father, with devotion, sincerity, and filial attachment. But this is my hope: if God wills, when he may will and how he may will, in the liturgy, the reform of the reform will take place. In spite of the gnashing of teeth, it will take place, because the future of the Church is at stake.

Damaging the liturgy means damaging our relationship with God and the concrete expression of our Christian faith. The Word of God and the doctrinal teaching of the Church are still listened to, but the souls that want to turn to God, to offer him the true sacrifice of praise and worship him, are no longer captivated by liturgies that are too horizontal, anthropocentric, and festive, often resembling noisy and vulgar cultural events. The media have completely invaded and turned into a spectacle the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass, the memorial of the death of Jesus on the cross for the salvation of our souls. The sense of mystery disappears through changes, through permanent adaptations, decided in autonomous and individual fashion in order to seduce our modern profaning mentalities, marked by sin, secularism, relativism, and the rejection of God.

In many western countries, we see the poor leaving the Catholic Church because it is under siege by ill-intentioned persons who style themselves intellectuals and despise the lowly and the poor. This is what the Holy Father must denounce loud and clear. Because a Church without the poor is no longer the Church, but a mere “club.” Today, in the West, how many temples are empty, closed, destroyed, or turned into profane structures in disdain of their sacredness and their original purpose. So I know how many priests and faithful there are who live their faith with extraordinary zeal and fight every day to preserve and enrich the dwellings of God.

(My emphasis)

Cf. Franziskus gegen ‘Reform der Reform’ bei der Liturgie

Cf. HINTERGRUND > Kardinal Robert Sarah – Vom Papst berufen und zugleich isoliert

The pastoral situation of same-sex couples – Pastoral Guidelines for Implementing #AmorisLaetitia, Archdiocese of Philadelphia, July 1, 2016

Abp. Chaput

Pastoral Guidelines for Implementing #AmorisLaetitia, Archdiocese of Philadelphia, July 1, 2016

The pastoral situation of same-sex couples

When two persons of the same sex present themselves openly in a parish as a same-sex couple (including those who may have entered into a same-sex union under civil law), pastors must judge prudently how best to address the situation, both for the sake of the authentic spiritual good of the persons involved, and the common good of the believing community. It’s important to remember that some same-sex couples do live together in chaste friendship and without sexual intimacy, and many pastors have had the experience of counseling such couples. The Church welcomes all men and women who honestly seek to encounter the Lord, whatever their circumstances. But two persons in an active, public same-sex relationship, no matter how sincere, offer a serious counter-witness to Catholic belief, which can only produce moral confusion in the community. Such a relationship cannot be accepted into the life of the parish without undermining the faith of the community, most notably the children. Finally, those living openly same-sex lifestyles should not hold positions of responsibility in a parish, nor should they carry out any liturgical ministry or function.

Can the divorced and civilly-remarried receive the sacraments? – Pastoral Guidelines for Implementing #AmorisLaetitia, Archdiocese of Philadelphia, July 1, 2016

Abp. Chaput

Pastoral Guidelines for Implementing #AmorisLaetitia, Archdiocese of Philadelphia, July 1, 2016

For Catholics and Christians who are divorced and civilly-remarried


Can the divorced and civilly-remarried receive the sacraments? As a general matter, baptized members of the Church are always in principle invited to the sacraments. The confessional’s doors are always open to the repentant and contrite of heart. What of Communion? Every Catholic, not only the divorced and civilly-remarried, must sacramentally confess all serious sins of which he or she is aware, with a firm purpose to change, before receiving the Eucharist. In some cases, the subjective responsibility of the person for a past action may be diminished. But the person must still repent and renounce the sin, with a firm purpose of amendment.

With divorced and civilly-remarried persons, Church teaching requires them to refrain from sexual intimacy. This applies even if they must (for the care of their children) continue to live under one roof. Undertaking to live as brother and sister is necessary for the divorced and civilly-remarried to receive reconciliation in the Sacrament of Penance, which could then open the way to the Eucharist. Such individuals are encouraged to approach the Sacrament of Penance regularly, having recourse to God’s great mercy in that sacrament if they fail in chastity.

Even where, for the sake of their children, they live under one roof in chaste continence and have received absolution (so that they are free from personal sin), the unhappy fact remains that, objectively speaking, their public state and condition of life in the new relationship are contrary to Christ’s teaching against divorce. Concretely speaking, therefore, where pastors give Communion to divorced and remarried persons trying to live chastely, they should do so in a manner that will avoid giving scandal or implying that Christ’s teaching can be set aside. In other contexts, also, care must be taken to avoid the unintended appearance of an endorsement of divorce and civil remarriage; thus, divorced and civilly remarried persons should not hold positions of responsibility in a parish (e.g. on a parish council), nor should they carry out liturgical ministries or functions (e.g., lector, extraordinary minister of Holy Communion).

This is a hard teaching for many, but anything less misleads people about the nature of the Eucharist and the Church. The grace of Jesus Christ is more than a pious cliché; it is a real and powerful seed of change in the believing heart. The lives of many saints bear witness that grace can take great sinners and, by its power of interior renewal, remake them in holiness of life. Pastors and all who work in the service of the Church should tirelessly promote hope in this saving mystery.

[English Speaking] Catholic Bishops’ Conferences in Europe on #AmorisLaetitia

The Catholic Bishops’ Conference of England and Wales

Background on the Apostolic Exhortation Amoris Laetitia, 08/04/2016 10:00 am
Resolution on the Apostolic Exhortation ‘Amoris Laetitia’, 15/04/2016 10:33 am
Q & A: Amoris Laetitia
Summary: Amoris Laetitia
CBCEW > CBCEW Home > About Us > The Pope > The Joy of Love

Irish Catholic Bishops’ Conference

Bishop Denis Nulty welcomes publication of Amoris Laetitia (The Joy of Love)
Bishop Kevin Doran welcomes Pope Francis’ Apostolic Exhortation on Love in the Family, ‘Amoris Laetitia’
Archbishop Eamon Martin welcomes the publication of Amoris Laetitia, The Joy of Love: On Love in the Family

[English Speaking] Catholic Bishops’ Conferences in Africa on #AmorisLaetitia

The Southern African Catholic Bishops’ Conference

Pope Francis on building the family. 15 April 2016

Pope Francis still affirms the Catholic Church’s teaching on Family Life and Marriage,” the Catholic Bishops declare. By Fr Paul Tatu

Uganda Episcopal Conference

– Post-Synodal Apostolic Apostolic Exhortation “Amoris Laetitia” The Joy of Love [Update 8/25/2016: Article can no longer be found]

Catholic Bishops’ Conference of Nigeria (CBCN)
The Zimbabwe Catholic Bishops’ Conference (ZCBC)

Pastoral letter: The Family in Zimbabwe in the light of Amoris Laetitia | Vatican Radio

The Ghana Catholic Bishops’ Conference (GCBC)

Ghana’s Bishops on Amoris Laetitia and nation’s family life

Catholic Bishops’ Conferences in Oceania on #AmorisLaetitia

Australian Catholic Bishops’ Conference

AUSTRALIAN CATHOLIC BISHOPS CONFERENCE:  “The Joy of Love” Pope Francis between the ideal and the real, Media release, 8 April 2016

The Joy of Love: Pope Francis sets out a human journey By Archbishop Mark Coleridge


– Cf. Apostolic Exhortation (papal document)

New Zealand Catholic Bishops Conference – the national body for the bishops of Aotearoa New Zealand

New Zealanders welcome Pope’s document on Marriage & the family